Internet Users Report Being Blocked From Websites

Every August we plan lessons, organize manipulatives, and make copies. But there’s one thing many of us rarely plan intentionally: how will students experience mathematics in my classroom this year?

During the first week, students aren’t just learning routines. They’re deciding if this is a place where their ideas matter and what it means to do math here. Imagine this: it’s October and a student gets stuck. Instead of immediately asking for help, they grab a tool, reread the problem, and try something. They do this not because they’re certain they’ll get it right, but because they’ve learned that struggling is part of learning. Classrooms like that don’t happen by accident; they begin during the first week of school.

Launching the year with a problem-solving mindset means focusing on more than routines and expectations. It means building a shared belief about what mathematics is and what students are capable of. The way we think shapes everything: how students respond to challenge, how they see themselves as mathematicians, whether they rely on you or learn to trust themselves, and whether math becomes a place to think rather than simply perform.

Related: Summer break nears for college students

I think one of the biggest mistakes we make at the beginning of the year is this: we spend weeks teaching students how to follow directions, without giving them the reason why or even an opportunity to think, try, and talk. We over-scaffold. We over-model. We over-explain. Almost every day in math. We do it because we want students to feel successful. We want the classroom to feel calm. We want routines. But sometimes in trying to help students feel successful… we accidentally communicate that math is about waiting for the teacher to show you what to do, or that math is doing what I show you and remembering how to do it on your own, or that mistakes mean you’re doing it wrong.

Why do they freeze when the problem looks different? Why do they rely on me for every step? It’s because students learn what math is by experiencing math. They learn that math is compliance. But if we shift our approach, they can also learn that math is about thinking and reasoning, and that everyone is capable of that.

I still remember the second day of school in my fifth-grade classroom. I put a word problem on the board that I knew students couldn’t solve immediately. Within seconds, students’ eyes darted around the room and hands shot into the air. Everything in me wanted to jump in and rescue them. After all, it was only the second day of school. Instead, I asked one question: “Can you start with what you know?” The room got quiet. One student pointed to a number they thought was important. Another disagreed. Someone sketched a quick model on their paper. Before long, students were talking to each other instead of looking at me. They didn’t solve it perfectly. They didn’t all use the same strategy. But something much more important happened. They experienced what it meant to do mathematics in our classroom. When we get stuck, we don’t wait for the teacher to rescue us. We think. We try. We listen. We build on each other’s ideas.

Looking back, I don’t remember the exact problem we solved that day. But I know my students left with a new belief about themselves as mathematicians. And that belief shaped everything we did for the rest of the year.

Related: Creating a Wedding Budget with Ethical Choices in Mind

How to launch the year differently

So what can you actually do at the beginning of the year without adding more, but making a shift toward more student thinking?

• Start with rich problems immediately. Give students a problem worth thinking about on the very first day. They don’t need to know every procedure before they begin making sense of mathematics. Rich problems invite students to use what they already know, share ideas, and discover that their thinking has value.
• Normalize productive struggle. We have to stop treating struggle like an emergency. Instead of rushing in to rescue students, plan for how you’ll support them when they grapple. Use prompts such as, “It’s okay not to know yet,” “What do you notice?” or “What could you try first?” Students begin to see that getting stuck isn’t failure. It’s part of learning mathematics.
• One of the biggest shifts we can make is talking less so students can think more. Instead of jumping in to explain, ask questions, pause, and listen. One teacher told me, “The students could carry much more of the conversation than I thought.” Remember: don’t say something a student could say themselves. Your job isn’t to perform the mathematics. It’s to facilitate the students’ thinking.
• Build discussion routines early. Students need explicit practice agreeing, disagreeing, asking questions, adding on to ideas, and restating someone else’s thinking. Establish a daily routine for students to share strategies and discuss mathematical ideas. Those conversations give students repeated opportunities to experience mathematics as something they do together. The deepest learning often happens when students compare, connect, and make sense of one another’s thinking.
• Celebrate thinking, not speed. The fastest student isn’t always the deepest thinker. Make it a habit to celebrate perseverance, revision, clear explanations, and thoughtful representations instead of speed. Thinking routines such as How Many? and Notice & Wonder communicate that every student has something valuable to contribute and that mathematics is about making sense of ideas together.

Students learn what math is by experiencing math. The first week simply gives us the first opportunity to shape that experience. Teacher friend, the beginning of the year is not just about routines. It’s about identity. Is math about answers or thinking? And the experiences we create answer those questions. If we want students to become problem solvers in March, then we have to start building those habits in August.

Every routine, every discussion, and every rich problem sends students a message about what mathematics is and who they can become as mathematicians. Long after students leave your classroom, they may not remember every strategy or standard, but they will remember what it felt like to believe they could think in math class.